Mangia Pizza

21 Wyckoff Ave, Waldwick, NJ 07463, USA

About Mangia Pizza

4.6 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    CEZANNE MARAGNI
    -
    February 17, 2026

    I think this will be one of my top favorite meals of 2026 and it’s only February 16th! The homemade red sauce was to die for. The sausage broccoli rabe pizza was one of the best slices I’ve her had and that means a lot coming from me since I am a traditional cheese slice or margarita slice girl. We also had the eggplant rollatini and the arugula salad which were both so yummy. One of the best arugula salads i’ve had! Truly so unbelievably delicious. And on the other hand the New Jersey Italian vibes, the welcoming family-like environment was truly so special. The hospitality of the owner, Freddie, was unmatched!! Gave us a pint of sauce on him as well as the most delicious cannoli dessert of hot dough topped with powdered sugar and cannoli cream! We were in a food coma. Will be back soon!!

    Allison L.
    -
    May 05, 2026

    I tried Mangia Pizza in Waldwick and honestly wasn’t impressed. The regular slice had a nice crisp, but the sauce was pretty bland and lacked flavor. The grandma pie was better—the sauce actually had some depth—but not enough to make up for everything else. What really turned me off was the service. I asked a simple question about whether they use different sauces on their pies, and Freddy responded sharply that he doesn’t answer those questions because it’s “secret.” I wasn’t asking for a recipe—just basic info—and the attitude felt unnecessarily rude. For the price (especially when you’re paying more for certain pies), I expected better quality and a better experience. Between the bland slice and the interaction, I won’t be returning. Go around the corner to Natalie's, for an exceptional pizza and lovely friendly people.

    Erica Q
    -
    July 05, 2026

    Our go to pizza in town. Love this pizza. The vodka pie is my favorite along with the regular plain and pepperoni pie. Always good.

    Ash N. Smith
    -
    March 04, 2026

    Delicious hot pizza pies right out of the oven ! This spot is your place to go for fantastic Italian dishes as well. Very gracious and friendly owners! Will return for more of their menu!

    Cheryl Pangaro
    -
    April 26, 2026

    I stumbled upon this by winning a gift certificate at a tricky tray. Recently one of the best finds in my dining experience over the years. Fred makes you feel like you're in his home. Checks on you, in addition to your waitress, to make sure all is good. His complimentary zeppelis are some of the best we have ever had. I have been here three times and all were delicious and family and friends love everything too. I was there last night celebrating my birthday and went up to Fred and booked two more reservations to bring more family and friends. ❤️

    Mangia Pizza

    Our Address

    21 Wyckoff Ave, Waldwick, NJ 07463, USA

    📬 Midland Park Community Deals Has Arrived!

    Our newest Midland Park Community Deals Mailer is packed with exclusive local offers, discounts, and specials from businesses right here in town! From restaurants and salons to home services, fitness, landscaping, and more — this mailer is all about supporting local and saving money.

    Inside you’ll find:
    ✅ Limited-time discounts
    ✅ Free consultations & trial offers
    ✅ Special promotions you won’t find online
    ✅ Trusted Midland Park businesses

    If you didn’t receive a mailer in your mailbox, don’t worry! Reach out to us directly and we’ll make sure one gets delivered to you.

    We’re proud to connect our community with the best local businesses — The Local Hub! way.

    Read More

    See Your Business Here!

    If you have any questions about how to get listed on our directory, contact us today!