Warning: not GF safe.
We really wanted to like this place. We told the waiter that multiple members of our party had celiac, and even though it was clearly written on the ticket that there were gluten allergies , both my wife and father-in-law were given pasta that had gluten contact. We happened to see a piece of spaghetti in the bowl of GF pasta with broccoli halfway through eating it. It turns out the cooks blanched the broccoli in the normal pasta cooking water. They apologized, offered us a replacement (though at that point of the meal we didn’t accept), and took the pasta off the bill, but nothing else.
This is no joke. It is a serious, dangerous lack of care that can make people extremely sick. For example, my wife is now dealing with pressure hives thanks to the carelessness of the restaurant.
We know that a place like this cannot and does not guarantee freedom from cross-contamination—but this was a whole other level of negligence. Please train your staff on the importance of this.
Ryan Castaldo
-
September 13, 2025
Never disappoints always full and content leaving here. Staff and owners are always so welcoming. Chefs kiss 😘
Eve S
-
September 17, 2025
We ordered online a large pie half mushroom half Hawaiian and it was exquisite. The flavor was wonderful and the crisp crust added to the whole presentation.
We also enjoyed a fresh salad, which was just the right amount for the three of us. Thank you so much for your quality foods that bless our table.!
P K
-
August 10, 2025
The service is prompt and friendly. Our server, Jack, was professional and knowledgeable, had a good sense of humor.
Food is always tasty and fresh. Accommodating when it comes to allergies. Love their lentil soup.
A pleasant place to eat.
Des KF
-
May 02, 2024
My clients picked this restaurant for lunch, and the order was called in. I got the specialty turkey sandwich. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked into a cute restaurant. The food wasn't ready yet and waited for about 10 more minutes. I paid and left. When I ate the sandwich, it was very good. Inloved the bread it came on. I had a good experience.
Our Address
Shopping Center, 85 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA
Claim Listing: Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Warning: not GF safe. We really wanted to like this place. We told the waiter that multiple members of our party had celiac, and even though it was clearly written on the ticket that there were gluten allergies , both my wife and father-in-law were given pasta that had gluten contact. We happened to see a piece of spaghetti in the bowl of GF pasta with broccoli halfway through eating it. It turns out the cooks blanched the broccoli in the normal pasta cooking water. They apologized, offered us a replacement (though at that point of the meal we didn’t accept), and took the pasta off the bill, but nothing else. This is no joke. It is a serious, dangerous lack of care that can make people extremely sick. For example, my wife is now dealing with pressure hives thanks to the carelessness of the restaurant. We know that a place like this cannot and does not guarantee freedom from cross-contamination—but this was a whole other level of negligence. Please train your staff on the importance of this.
Never disappoints always full and content leaving here. Staff and owners are always so welcoming. Chefs kiss 😘
We ordered online a large pie half mushroom half Hawaiian and it was exquisite. The flavor was wonderful and the crisp crust added to the whole presentation. We also enjoyed a fresh salad, which was just the right amount for the three of us. Thank you so much for your quality foods that bless our table.!
The service is prompt and friendly. Our server, Jack, was professional and knowledgeable, had a good sense of humor. Food is always tasty and fresh. Accommodating when it comes to allergies. Love their lentil soup. A pleasant place to eat.
My clients picked this restaurant for lunch, and the order was called in. I got the specialty turkey sandwich. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked into a cute restaurant. The food wasn't ready yet and waited for about 10 more minutes. I paid and left. When I ate the sandwich, it was very good. Inloved the bread it came on. I had a good experience.