Pizzaiolo by Brothers

Shopping Center, 85 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA

About Pizzaiolo by Brothers

4 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Rachel Roesch
    -
    July 12, 2026

    We ordered delivery a few days ago- a large pizza, buffalo chicken tenders, Italian hero, and kids tenders. The buffalo tenders have always been a staple order in our house but the last few orders the chicken is a bit strange- rubbery, and the texture is off. Not sure where they are sourcing the chicken from but it’s noticeable even with the breading. The Italian hero was a bit short on meat too, which I remember always being delicious, so that was a surprise- but still tasted good. Hoping that was a one off. Pizza was the usual, thus the 3 stars.

    John Westrich
    -
    January 17, 2026

    I really want to like this pizza but I can’t. I understand teach his/ her own. This is far from what one could consider as thin crust pizza. No way. The dough was very chewy and not very tasty. I rarely put any pizza down but it is on the disappointing side. If I did not have a coupon I would have not bothered. The app was a bit clunky too and would not allow me to add the coupon. With 1 topping not close to being worth $25.

    S U
    -
    May 09, 2026

    Usually good, but last two visits my food was not very hot. Also server should ask if you want a salad. Most places include salad so we expected that. My friend asked about salad as entree was served. That was too late to order one.

    Des KF
    -
    May 02, 2024

    My clients picked this restaurant for lunch, and the order was called in. I got the specialty turkey sandwich. When I arrived I parked in the plaza lot. I walked into a cute restaurant. The food wasn't ready yet and waited for about 10 more minutes. I paid and left. When I ate the sandwich, it was very good. Inloved the bread it came on. I had a good experience.

    Frank Filippelli
    -
    August 11, 2023

    This is a fine place with a beautiful atmosphere. The service it good, the interior design is almost perfect, and the food good. But my one big complaint is they claim to make brick oven pizza and it’s more like faux brick oven. First of all there is no break oven to speak of. It is actually a modern stainless steel oven in the shape of a brick oven and I believe it’s gas powered. That being said the pizza is definitely good but it’s really missing that natural flavor you get from a traditional brick oven set up. It tastes more like a standard American pie. On the bright side, the focaccia bread is pretty good and the Barata cheese is amazing.

    Pizzaiolo by Brothers

    Our Address

    Shopping Center, 85 Godwin Ave, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA

    📬 Midland Park Community Deals Has Arrived!

    Our newest Midland Park Community Deals Mailer is packed with exclusive local offers, discounts, and specials from businesses right here in town! From restaurants and salons to home services, fitness, landscaping, and more — this mailer is all about supporting local and saving money.

    Inside you’ll find:
    ✅ Limited-time discounts
    ✅ Free consultations & trial offers
    ✅ Special promotions you won’t find online
    ✅ Trusted Midland Park businesses

    If you didn’t receive a mailer in your mailbox, don’t worry! Reach out to us directly and we’ll make sure one gets delivered to you.

    We’re proud to connect our community with the best local businesses — The Local Hub! way.

    Read More

    See Your Business Here!

    If you have any questions about how to get listed on our directory, contact us today!