Rosario’s Trattoria & Pizzeria

James N.

-

July 26, 2025

Came here upon recommendation from a golfer and was impressed by the food and service. Friendly and old school Italian decor, Rosario offers an expansive menu and with lots of specials, even better that is BYOB. Pastas are cooked perfectly al dente and sauce work is silky smooth. Portions are large, prepare to take leftovers home. Didn't have the pizza but that would be next, I hear the square pies are excellent.

C R

-

October 21, 2025

I ordered 3 pizzas for delivery for an event. 1 cheese, 1 pepperoni, and 1 half sausage. The pizza was amazing. The mozzarella cheese on the pies was delicious. The toppings were very generous and great quality. The sauce, the crust, definitely some of the best pizza I've ever had. Everyone in our group loved the pizza. I'll definitely we back. Btw the delivery driver was super nice too. A++++ highly recommended.

Michael Scolnic

-

May 18, 2025

I have tried many pizzas near Ridgewood and I do think this is the best pizza in Bergen county. All of the pizzas are good, but the spicy pomodoro pizza is… incredible. The sauce is spicy, the crunch is perfect, somehow still cheesy… I can’t even describe really how perfect it is. Other food here is good (e.g., branzino, eggplant parm, the soups) but the pizza is really the star. Restaurant is a nice vibe in and of itself but the pizza is really why I love this place.

Jeremy Oestreicher

-

October 18, 2025

Service was perfectly fine, but the food here is just not good. Way underseasoned, old seafood, recipes from the 90s that should have stayed in the 90s. Food tasted like the restaurant doesn’t care. No passion at all.

Steven Foglio

-

November 23, 2025

Friendly staff. Great food. Big portions! One of my favorite local spots to go to