My experience from start to finish was incredible. I was greeted as soon as I entered the bakery. When I explained what I was looking for, creative ideas were immediately shared. I told Michelle that the cake was for a dog birthday party and we talked about rescue dogs for a bit. The funfetti cake with buttercream was beautiful and delicious! Everyone said how good it was! :)
Bottom line: dog people + cute Disney inspired bakery = amazing combination
Jackie D.
-
August 22, 2025
Wish Upon a Pastry is so good! They satisfy the urge for a Disney baked treat without leaving New Jersey. Their homemade marshmallows have the perfect texture. The decorated sugar cookies are almost too beautiful too eat, but they taste too yummy to just look at! The smells in the store made it hard to choose just one treat. And speaking of smells, their store-made scented candles make me feel like I'm walking through Disney World. We will be back to try their vegan, dairy-free ice cream!
Ellen Hillman
-
November 11, 2025
Fantastic designs and fabulous flavors! What a delicious spread of desserts. The Disney flavor macarons were a huge hit. The mini donuts were such a tiny treat. The designs in the cookies were so creative...and delicious! The cookies had just the right balance of flavor and weren't overly sweet, which can happen with iced cookies. Wish upon a pastry is THE place to get your special desserts, or just a fun cookie, cakesicle or macaron.
Daisy Castro Ramos
-
May 16, 2025
I cannot express how overjoyed we were with the cake we ordered for my daughter’s birthday! As a huge Billie Eilish fan, she had a vision for her special cake that perfectly combined her love for Billie with a charming coquette theme. The dynamic duo, Michelle and Torre brought her dream to life with stunning precision. From the moment we placed the order, their attention to detail was like no other. The cake not only looked incredible—complete with the signature Billie lyrics font and delicate coquette touches—but it also tasted absolutely delicious! Each layer was moist and flavorful. Thank you from the bottom of my heart, for making my daughter’s birthday unforgettable and for creating the cake she truly wished for! We couldn’t have asked for a better experience, her smile says it all!
Erin Duby
-
July 26, 2024
There’s not enough words to describe how delicious these treats are and how much I love this bakery! I have ordered cookies from wish upon a pastry several times now, and I could not be happier every time I pick up a new order! Michelle is so wonderful and makes the ordering process so easy, she always listens to my ideas and somehow translates that into beautiful cookies! Everyone always raves about how perfect they are, and the beauty is only surpassed by how yummy these treats taste!
The bakery itself is amazing, and while I’ve only pre-ordered cookies before, I usually always try something new when I stop in. We’ve tried several different homemade ice cream flavors- my son is a huge fan of the cotton candy and my fave is the toasted coconut! The cupcakes and cream puffs are also incredible. There’s always single cookies (usually Disney themed!) in the front and we always grab a few of those too!
Michelle and Torre are so kind, attentive to detail, and the love they put into their creations really shows. I can’t wait for my next event so I can order more! :)
Our Address
26 Goffle Rd Suite 6, Midland Park, NJ 07432, USA
Claim Listing: wish upon a pastry
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
My experience from start to finish was incredible. I was greeted as soon as I entered the bakery. When I explained what I was looking for, creative ideas were immediately shared. I told Michelle that the cake was for a dog birthday party and we talked about rescue dogs for a bit. The funfetti cake with buttercream was beautiful and delicious! Everyone said how good it was! :) Bottom line: dog people + cute Disney inspired bakery = amazing combination
Wish Upon a Pastry is so good! They satisfy the urge for a Disney baked treat without leaving New Jersey. Their homemade marshmallows have the perfect texture. The decorated sugar cookies are almost too beautiful too eat, but they taste too yummy to just look at! The smells in the store made it hard to choose just one treat. And speaking of smells, their store-made scented candles make me feel like I'm walking through Disney World. We will be back to try their vegan, dairy-free ice cream!
Fantastic designs and fabulous flavors! What a delicious spread of desserts. The Disney flavor macarons were a huge hit. The mini donuts were such a tiny treat. The designs in the cookies were so creative...and delicious! The cookies had just the right balance of flavor and weren't overly sweet, which can happen with iced cookies. Wish upon a pastry is THE place to get your special desserts, or just a fun cookie, cakesicle or macaron.
I cannot express how overjoyed we were with the cake we ordered for my daughter’s birthday! As a huge Billie Eilish fan, she had a vision for her special cake that perfectly combined her love for Billie with a charming coquette theme. The dynamic duo, Michelle and Torre brought her dream to life with stunning precision. From the moment we placed the order, their attention to detail was like no other. The cake not only looked incredible—complete with the signature Billie lyrics font and delicate coquette touches—but it also tasted absolutely delicious! Each layer was moist and flavorful. Thank you from the bottom of my heart, for making my daughter’s birthday unforgettable and for creating the cake she truly wished for! We couldn’t have asked for a better experience, her smile says it all!
There’s not enough words to describe how delicious these treats are and how much I love this bakery! I have ordered cookies from wish upon a pastry several times now, and I could not be happier every time I pick up a new order! Michelle is so wonderful and makes the ordering process so easy, she always listens to my ideas and somehow translates that into beautiful cookies! Everyone always raves about how perfect they are, and the beauty is only surpassed by how yummy these treats taste! The bakery itself is amazing, and while I’ve only pre-ordered cookies before, I usually always try something new when I stop in. We’ve tried several different homemade ice cream flavors- my son is a huge fan of the cotton candy and my fave is the toasted coconut! The cupcakes and cream puffs are also incredible. There’s always single cookies (usually Disney themed!) in the front and we always grab a few of those too! Michelle and Torre are so kind, attentive to detail, and the love they put into their creations really shows. I can’t wait for my next event so I can order more! :)